Get Quote
Call Harley & Sons1300 442 753

Roof Restoration vs. Roof Replacement

When you need a new roof, it can be tempting just to replace the whole thing. Many homeowners are tempted by the idea of getting a brand new home addition in one fell swoop.

However, there are many reasons why you might want to consider restoring your existing roof instead of replacing it completely. Here’s what you should know before making this choice:

What is roof restoration?

Roof restoration is the process of restoring the original appearance of a roof, which may be damaged by natural or man-made factors.

Roof restoration includes repairing and replacing damaged roofing materials, as well as removing debris from the roof. Roof restoration is required when there are serious damages to a roof that need to be repaired before they become worse and cause leaks or other problems.

Roof restoration can extend the life of your roof by several years if it is done properly. This makes it an important investment for homeowners who want their roofs to last as long as possible without having to replace them completely.

What Does a Roof Restoration Involve?

The roofing contractor will remove existing tiles and granules and inspect your roof for structural damage or rot. If there is no damage, you may opt for an overlay instead of a complete tear-off and replacement.

If the underlying sheathing is sound, the contractor can install new underlayment, which will help prevent leaks from occurring in the future. They’ll also apply new felt paper to protect your home from water damage during storms and heavy rainfalls.

If additional repairs are needed on top of this basic repair process, for instance, if you need to replace damaged flashing, those repairs will be made before new tiles are installed overtop of them so that they don’t have to come back out again later on down the road due to another issue arising after work has been completed.

What Are the Big Benefits of Roof Restoration?

Roof replacement is an expensive process that often requires tearing off your old tiles and installing a brand-new one, which can be costly and time-consuming. However, if you’re looking for a more affordable roof replacement alternative, you may want to consider restoring your home’s existing tiles.

Roof restoration is less expensive than replacing your entire roof; it costs approximately half as much as an entirely new roof would cost! This means that you don’t have to worry about spending too much money on repairing or replacing your home’s exterior after getting hit by hail damage or another storm event.

Roof Replacement

Roof Replacement is a more permanent solution to the problem of your roof. If you want to ensure that your roof will last for many years, this may be the best option for you. It’s also usually more expensive than other options because it involves removing and replacing all the existing materials on your home’s exterior.

A roof replacement project can take some time to complete. This can be tricky if you need a temporary fix in order to stay dry in an emergency situation while waiting for repairs or replacements to be completed.

When Do You Need a Roof Replacement?

When you need to replace your roof depends on the circumstances. If your roof is old, damaged, or leaking, it may be time to consider replacing it. While it’s not always easy to determine if you need a new roof, some signs can help you decide.

  • The age of your home is one factor in determining whether or not it’s time for a new one. If your house was built before 1990 and has been in use for more than 20 years, replacing its tiles may be recommended as part of routine maintenance. This will prevent any problems from arising later on down the road.

What is The Cost of Roof Replacement in Melbourne?

The cost of roof replacement can range from $10,000+/- to $20,000+/-, depending on your home’s size and the project’s complexity.

This information is based on our quotes, and we looked at the average costs for homeowners replacing their roofs, both residential and commercial.

In general, some factors will increase or decrease the cost of your roof replacement:

  • Location – Remote areas or those with difficult access will usually have higher costs due to these factors. For example, suppose you live in a rural area where it is difficult to get materials delivered, and construction workers need to travel long distances. In that case, this will increase labor costs which will be reflected in your final price tag.
  • Climate – Areas with higher rainfall also tend to have more damage caused by storms such as hail storms, so they may require more repairs when compared to drier climates. 
  • Roof Style – Certain styles, such as tiles, tend not only to look better but also last longer than others. So, the price will be higher.

Roof Restoration or Roof Replacement?

When it comes to roof restoration vs. roof replacement, there are a lot of factors to consider. The most important one is your budget. While you can always make your home look more beautiful by restoring its original tiles, replacing them with new ones will be more cost-effective if they are beyond repair.

If you want to spend less on roof repairs, you can opt for a full roof replacement. This would involve removing all the old tiles and replacing them with new ones. If you want the job done right, you should hire a professional roofing contractor with experience installing roofs.


Roof restoration is an excellent option if you want to keep your roof in good shape but don’t want to replace it with a new one. It saves money on installation and materials while providing many of the same benefits as a replacement. However, if you have significant damage or need a change in style or colour, then roof replacement may be your best choice.


How do I know if my roof needs restoration or replacement?

If your roof has minor issues such as leaks, damaged shingles, or faded appearance, restoration may be sufficient. However, if your roof is severely damaged, old, or nearing the end of its lifespan, it might require replacement.

Can I do a partial restoration instead of replacing the entire roof?

Yes, if only certain sections of your roof are damaged, it’s possible to perform a partial restoration by focusing on those areas rather than replacing the entire structure.

Are there any advantages to choosing a full roof replacement over restoration?

While more expensive upfront, a full roof replacement provides you with an opportunity to upgrade to more durable materials and improve the overall insulation and energy efficiency of your home.

Get An Inspection

  • Hidden
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.